Wednesday, October 9, 2024

The continued bull case for gold

Most people, especially those in the West, mostly perceive gold as an inflation hedge. After some increase in gold prices when inflation rate was high, gold prices continued its path up even faster even when inflation rate dropped to levels before the big jump since the pandemic. I was bullish about gold in the long term since at least early 2022. Here is what I said in February 2022 in my blog.

 

Gold will slump from this level too but will get out of the slump before all the other assets. The time of its bottom could be in 2023. It will likely have a strong bull market from there, appreciating many times. Gold companies will take longer to bottom, say another year after gold bottoms.”

 

Gold prices have fluctuated in most of 2022 and 2023. Since late 2023, it has gone up by 50%. Many gold producers see their stock prices more than double. Gold prices may experience some retrace and adjustment. But is this the peak of gold prices?

 

I don’t think so, because my initial bull case about gold was about much more than inflation.

 

1.       Gold is an inflation hedge. In the near term, inflation rate is likely to drop even further. But unless the supply chains have been largely friend-shored from production in China, the potential huge inflation shock from a confrontation between China and the US about Taiwan is still there. As the friend-shoring is going on, a lot of production will experience cost increase with new production bases, infrastructure, and supply chains. needing to be built. Producing in China in the first place is because it is cheaper to produce there.

 

2.      West governments, especially the U.S. government, have increased the spending substantially during the pandemic, and have largely kept the spending level even if the pandemic has passed. If there is any weakness in economy, more spending increases are likely. This inflation impetus will be there in any foreseeable future. Some of the spendings, like those under the CHIPS Act or Inflation Reduction Act, will eventually have some effect on reducing inflation. But any of such effects will be uncertain and far away.

 

3.      Such spendings have raised government deficit substantially, especially in the US. As a result, the Federal Reserve have not had 2% inflation as a hard target as before. The Fed have to tolerate somewhat higher inflation rate to erase the deficit a bit more over time, as long as the inflation rate is not much higher than 3%.

 

4.      Chinese economic decline is a story that I have declared since 2011. This decline has started exactly when I declared it. It means that there is a lack of investment options because all the other investment options would be losing money. The low trust in Chinese government means that more and more people will choose gold as the main investment option.

 

5.      India’s economic rise is a story that I have declared at least 10 years ago. This rise started exactly about the time I declared it. As Indian households become more affluent, they will buy more gold given their strong preference for gold. Note that China and India are among the five largest economies in the world with about 35% of world population.

 

6.      After the sanctions on Russia after its illegal invasion of Ukraine, many developing country governments realized the length the US and West would go using US dollars as a weapon. It is only natural that they will increase gold’s proportion in their reserves.

 

7.      Emerging markets have been in a funk, especially compared to the US, since 2011, also the time that I predicted this funk. The recent inflation surge since pandemic also hit them the hardest even if the Western media don’t usually pay much attention in its coverage. The households in these markets would increase their gold holding as well.

 

8.     The world has become much more uncertain and has many more conflicts. These involves the confrontation between the West and countries like Russia, Iran, China, and North Korea in the remapping of the Pax Americana system since the end of World War II. These also involve the tectonic political shift within the Western countries. For example, many people don’t think the period after this coming US election will be peaceful. This uncertainty will increase gold buying from everyone.

 

9.      In the very near term, in November, there could be two potential inflation shocks. One is for sure, the other depends on the election outcome. The first is the inevitable attack of Israel on Iran’s nuclear facilities and maybe even destabilize the Iranian regime. Israel now have achieved overwhelming military advantage over Iran and its affiliates. The sky of Iran is almost all open to Israel fighter jets. It would be stupid not to press this advantage and eliminate or at least set back Iran’s nuclear program and related infrastructure. But Israelis must have been told that they should wait until the election is over, and they probably will do that. The second is a Trump win. He pledged an across the board tariff increase. Even if he is not able to deliver as much as he pledged, it will still lead to a one time big inflation shock.

 

I mentioned in my initial predictions in early 2022 that I thought gold will appreciate many times. I had the target of about 10,000 an ounce in my mind and I still believe so. I always hate the people who give a pie in the sky forecast. There are many such people during the 2000 tech bubble for example. But if I am honest, that is the gold price target in foreseeable future.

 

Gold producers could see their stock prices increase a lot more than gold price. They are a natural leveraged play on gold price increases as their reserves will be revalued. Silver prices and silver producers could see crazy price increases too. The most conservative bet and maybe also the best bet of a buy and hold strategy may be Agnico Eagle Mines (AEM). Some of the silver producers like First Majestic Silver have shown very clear double bottoming pattern even on quarterly price chart. Even gold and silver related plays may go down by a good percentage in the near term, buying on the dip would still be the right approach.


黄金牛市的持续

 大多数人,尤其是西方人,大多认为黄金是一种通胀对冲工具。在前段时间通胀率高企时,金价曾上涨,但即使通胀率已降至疫情爆发前的水平,金价仍继续更快上涨。至少从 2022 年初开始,我就对黄金的长期前景持乐观态度。这是我在 2022 2 月博客里说的话。

 

“黄金也将从这个水平下跌,但会比其他所有资产更早走出低迷。黄金触底的时间可能是在 2023 年。从那时起,黄金可能会迎来强劲的牛市,升值很多倍。黄金公司需要更长的时间才能触底,比如说在黄金触底一年后。”

 

黄金价格在 2022 年和 2023 年的大部分时间里都在波动。自 2023 年底以来,黄金价格已上涨了 50%。许多黄金生产商的股价上涨了一倍以上。黄金价格可能会经历一些回撤和调整。但这是金价的顶峰吗?

 

我不这么认为,因为我最初看涨黄金的理由远不止通胀。

 

1. 黄金是一种通胀对冲工具。短期内,通胀率可能会进一步下降。但除非供应链在很大程度上与中国的生产挂钩,否则中美在台湾问题上的对抗可能带来的巨大通胀冲击仍然存在。随着供应链的不断转移,许多生产将面临成本增加,需要建立新的生产基地、基础设施和供应链。在中国生产首先是因为那里生产更便宜。

 

2. 西方政府,尤其是美国政府,在疫情期间大幅增加了支出,即使疫情过去,支出也基本保持不变。如果经济出现任何疲软,支出可能会进一步增加。这种通胀动力在可预见的未来都会存在。一些支出,如《CHIPS法案》或《通胀降低法案》下的支出,最终会对降低通胀产生一定影响。但任何这种影响都是不确定的,而且遥不可及。

 

3. 此类支出大幅增加了政府赤字,尤其是在美国。因此,美联储不再像以前那样将2%的通胀率作为硬性目标。美联储必须容忍略高的通胀率,以便随着时间的推移进一步消除赤字,只要通胀率不超过3%

 

4. 中国经济衰退是我自2011年以来就宣布的故事。这种衰退正是在我宣布它的时候开始的。这意味着缺乏投资选择,因为所有其它投资选择都是亏钱的。对中国政府的低信任意味着越来越多的人将选择黄金作为主要投资选择。

 

5. 印度经济崛起是我至少10年前就宣布的故事。这种崛起正是在我宣布它的时候开始的。随着印度家庭变得更加富裕,他们将购买更多的黄金,因为他们对黄金有强烈的偏好。请注意,中国和印度是世界五大经济体之一,两个国家人口也约占世界人口的 35%

 

6. 在俄罗斯非法入侵乌克兰后,和西方对其实施制裁后,许多发展中国家政府意识到美国和西方国家会使用美元作为武器。他们自然会增加黄金在其储备中的比例。

 

7. 2011 年以来,新兴市场一直处于低迷状态,尤其是与美国相比,这也是我预测这种低迷的时候。尽管西方媒体通常不会过多关注疫情的报道,但疫情爆发以来的近期通胀飙升也给它们带来了最严重的打击。这些市场的家庭也会增加黄金持有量。

 

8. 世界变得更加不确定,冲突也更多。这涉及到西方与俄罗斯、伊朗、中国和朝鲜等国家在博弈以达到一个二战结束以来映射美国治下的和平体系中后的新的平衡。这还涉及到西方国家内部的政治结构转变。例如,许多人认为即将到来的美国大选之后的时期会有暴力出现。这种不确定性将增加所有人的黄金购买量。

 

9. 在近期,即 11 月,可能会出现两次潜在的通胀冲击。一个是肯定的,另一个取决于选举结果。第一个是以色列不可避免地袭击伊朗核设施,甚至可能破坏伊朗政权。以色列现在已取得对伊朗及其盟友的压倒性军事优势。伊朗的天空几乎全部向以色列战斗机敞开。如果现在不利用这一优势消除或至少挫败伊朗的核计划和相关基础设施,那将是愚蠢的。但以色列人一定被告知他们应该等到选举结束后,他们可能会这样做。第二个是特朗普获胜。他承诺全面提高关税。即使他无法完全兑现承诺,部分增加关税也会导致一次性的巨额通胀冲击。

 

我在2022最初的预测中提到,我认为黄金会升值很多倍。我心中的目标是每盎司差不多 10,000 美元,我仍然相信这一点。我总是讨厌那些给出不切实际的预测的人。例如,在 2000 年的科技泡沫期间,就有很多这样的人。但如果我说实话,那就是可预见的未来的黄金价格目标。

 

黄金生产商的股价可能会比黄金价格上涨得多。由于他们的储备将被重新估值,因此它们是黄金价格上涨的自然杠杆投资。白银价格和白银生产商也可能会经历疯狂的价格上涨。最保守的标的,也可能是买入并持有策略的最佳标的可能是 Agnico Eagle Mines (AEM)。一些白银生产商,如 First Majestic Silver,即使在季度价格图上也显示出非常明显的双底模式。即使黄金和白银相关的股票在短期内可能会大幅下跌,逢低买入仍然是正确的做法。